Start Learning Korean in the next 30 Seconds with
a Free Lifetime Account

Or sign up using Facebook

-을 수 없다 VS -을 수가 없다

CaoMei513
New in Town
Posts: 4
Joined: October 31st, 2007 1:29 am

-을 수 없다 VS -을 수가 없다

Postby CaoMei513 » July 16th, 2010 5:33 pm

Hi everyone, just a quick question:

Is there a difference at all between -을 수 없다 and -을 수가 없다? I see the former more often of course, but I hear the latter pretty often in songs. Is there a subtle difference in meaning or something?

Thanks for any help!

trutherous
Expert on Something
Posts: 870
Joined: February 8th, 2010 8:55 am

Postby trutherous » July 19th, 2010 2:20 am

만야그미~ --대답하시겠어요?

그러면 내가 해 볼까요?

Well, hello CaoMei513, nice to meet you and welcome to KoreanClass101 -- I am a fellow student by the name of George.

Is there a difference at all between -을 수 없다 and -을 수가 없다?


It is my opinion and experience that these two phrases you asked about are exactly identical in meaning.

-을(future tense of some verb -example: to eat 먹다 -먹을) 수(in this case indicates ability/probability/ or likelihood) 없다(doesn't exist/is not)

-을 수 없다 - can't do such and such, or such and such is not permitted
-을 수가 없다? (same meaning but using subject particle "가")

if the phrase is used with the contrast particle "는" it would convey the meaning that "only that" couldn't be done.
먹을 수는 없다? "I/you/he can't eat (but maybe could drink or something else)"

manyakumi
Expert on Something
Posts: 679
Joined: January 26th, 2008 6:49 am

Postby manyakumi » July 19th, 2010 11:07 am

Good explanations, George.
Thank you for the quick response.

Hello, CaoMei513, it's nice to see you here.
My name is Sean and I'm not a fellow student. lol

Since George already gave us the good answer,
I'm just going to show you some additional usages and meanings.

trutherous wrote:-을 수 없다 - can't do such and such, or such and such is not permitted
-을 수가 없다? (same meaning but using subject particle "가")

This is right.
There's no difference between two but the nuance.
Usually we add 가 in order to emphasize it.

믿을 수 없어요.
I can't believe you.

믿을 수가 없어요.
I can't (even) believe you.


Above two are the same in the meaning.
Though the second one has the nuance of "even" slightly.


trutherous wrote:if the phrase is used with the contrast particle "는" it would convey the meaning that "only that" couldn't be done.
먹을 수는 없다? "I/you/he can't eat (but maybe could drink or something else)"

Very good insight.
However, that sentence can have two meanings.

먹을 수는 없다.

I/you/he can't eat (but maybe could drink or something else)
I/you/he can't eat (should not better eat)


If you give a stress more on 는, it means the first one.
:D

timandyou
Expert on Something
Posts: 601
Joined: March 12th, 2010 9:12 am

Thanks George and Manyakumi

Postby timandyou » July 20th, 2010 12:50 am

:o

Thanks for your help, George and Manyakumi,
I am sure that CaoMei513 learned a lot from both of you.
I have nothing to add on this question.

"Thank you so much~~!"
cheers,


Tim 8)

Return to “Learn All About Korean (한국어에 관한 모든 것)”